Top Ten Tuesday: Unpopular Bookish Opinions

Top Ten Tuesday banner

Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly meme created by The Broke and the Bookish and now hosted by Jana @ That Artsy Reader Girl, wherein each week bloggers list out their Top Ten.

This week’s prompt was something I thought over whether or not to do – I don’t generally get controversial, so I was considering changing it to something else. Eventually I decided on just doing it, though – some of the opinions below could’ve done with more explanation, but I figured brevity is better. Keep in mind, these are ~somewhat~ light-hearted and I am not calling anyone out. The gloves are coming off, though, folks!

Collecting different editions of the same book is wasteful

Yeah, I know what most people will say – Who are YOU to decide how people should spend their money etc etc – but honestly, in the recent years, I have seen book Twitter and bookstagram kinda obsessed with getting different editions of the same book.

Some of the #booksfortrade posts I come across are just people looking to collect every damn edition of the same book, including ARCs which just feels a bit materialistic (not to mention encourages sale of ARCs in few cases)? I mean, the story is mostly the same in all those books, so it is probably not obtained for reading? Also, some get foreign editions and I can’t speak for whether they know the language or not, but mostly it seems like a cover buy.

Oh, if the specific editions have some extra material like a bonus story or something, then I get it. And I also get supporting the author, but I feel a better use would be to get multiple copies to share with someone else instead, like a library?

Spoilers are not the end of the world, jeez!

Personally, I don’t mind spoilers in the least. Heck, spoil me if I am excited for the book! I wanna know before I go in what to look out for. The fear of spoilers doesn’t make sense to me, especially when the book in question is not a mystery or something. You see these posts go up like a month before a hyped book release like – ‘don’t you dare post spoilers or you are fucking dead to me’ sort of thing, which I am always like chill.

For the sake of my reviews, though, yes, I try to be spoiler-free. I don’t want to ruin people’s fun. But honestly, it is the journey to that reveal that matters, not just the reveal,  you know. So chill out the next time you want to pounce on someone for spoiling something!

I don’t see the point of writing a review for a book that I DNF

Now, the opinions over writing DNF reviews are varied in the book community, but I have a simple rule – didn’t read the whole book? Don’t review it. It is why I never get those samplers galleys from Netgalley (why even have those on there???) because I feel reviews are written for the whole thing – story, characters, and everything. I mean, if a book was frustrating enough, I guess you can just write – I DNF’d it because it was frustrating? But a proper review, nah!

You don’t HAVE to read any book

I am guilty of this, frequently in the past, of going like – OMG YOU HAVE TO READ THIS BOOK! Having enthusiasm for your favorite book and promoting it to your friends/followers/strangers-on-the-street/cryptids-in-the-forest is one thing, but there’s no such thing as a must-read book. Yes, even that book you think should be required reading or whatever.

Also relevant to this are those lists going like – 100 books to read before you die etc etc. No, there is no book that is universally liked. People have their own tastes – making some book the shining example of What You Should Read is only intimidating, and it often feels like you are reading it wrong if you don’t like the book. It also gives rise to a sort of elitism among book readers, like ‘I have read this book, why haven’t you read it yet’.

My advise to any reader – new, or old – is this: read what you like, figure out what you like to read, and read those; you are less likely to get disappointed that way. Read new things out of curiosity, not peer pressure.

Not liking a Hyped book doesn’t make you special

Speaking of elitism, there is kind of snob in reader circles sometimes who take extra joy in ruining other’s joy over their favorite books, especially if those books are popular. They are assholes.

Sure, like I said above, no book is universally liked. You didn’t like a book? Fine. Find someone else who didn’t like it, and maybe chat with them. Some of us do like to think we are different from the herd or whatever, when we don’t get why a certain book is popular, or find it cringe-y that someone likes it. I still see hate for many popular books that just seem petty in their reasoning, and speaks more like they expected it to be some kind of High Literature book and it wasn’t so it was trash.

If a book was problematic, sure, maybe discuss that. Heck, let others know, even! Even popular books aren’t perfect and there are bound to be troubling stuff, but again there’s a whole nuanced rulebook when it comes to how to deal with this situations. But yeah, judging a person for liking a popular book, when you don’t know the context, is not right IMO.

I like villain stories more that heroic ones

Probably problematic to side with villains, but a girl loves dark sympathetic villanous arcs and is not that apologetic about it.

Expecting good diversity is not Censorship

Well, this isn’t an Unpopular Opinion as much as it is a declaration. When there are problematic books and people call it out, immediately there are people going like ‘This is Censorship’ and ‘Why are you forcing diversity?’ And yeah, those people often have something in common. And they also think that diversity shouldn’t matter for a book. (One guess as to why)

Look, a book being diverse doesn’t mean I will give it a glowing review just for being diverse, but yes, I am more likely to pick up that book over a generic one. Publishing is fucking white, okay? And the readership is quite diverse! Reflecting the world, or even emulating it (in case of fantasy/scifi) is a good choice.

Every few months, there is another stupid thinkpiece about how diversity is killing the industry and ya-da ya-da. But I see more love for books these days, love that arises because they feel represented in that book. As a reviewer, this probably goes against the whole ‘don’t have bias’ thing, but reading is such a personal thing, okay?

And back to the problematic book thing – its not a big SJW thing to demand that books be better, publishing be better, and for those who peddle harmful things in books be asked to change them.

Cover changes aren’t really that big of a deal

OH god if I have to see one more post moaning about how covers don’t match for their collection….Like, the content inside the book is important, okay! And sure, we love pretty covers and such, but if it is good, and just doesn’t match the copy of the prequel you had? NOT A BIG DEAL!

Which of these books have you read? Any of these your favorites, too?

10 thoughts on “Top Ten Tuesday: Unpopular Bookish Opinions

  1. I completely agree that collecting boots in general, is a complete waste. The only way I’d have more than one edition is if I wanted to mark it up for different reasons (like different times reading it in my life or because I was specifically analyzing it). I don’t have a ton of money so I’d rather use that money on books I can’t get from my library than buying the same book over and over.

  2. I mean I don’t really care if people collect 50 editions but I don’t get why they do it for like so many books. I could get it if it’s a treasured series or author but for some it’s like EVERYTHING they like – ah well, to each their own. I’m too cheap for that shit lol

    Thank you for talking about the hype thing. I said that in mine too. I’m so over people thinking they are edgy by hating on things that people love. Like it’s fine to review something and if you don’t like it then fine, say so but dont go riling up every fan there is by saying how that author is trash. Like stop lol

    Amen about the diversity and I’m cringing at thinking about how many people are going to say something completely different to that sentiment this week.

    • Yeah well if you’re cheap, then I am too. Maybe it’s because I was never rich or even had much of a disposable income. I love books, but I love reading a lot of books throughout my life – so I find it weird that people are into collecting books like some sort of collectible

      About the diversity thing, well every few months there’s a dumpster fire in Twitter over that same thing. I’m kinda used to it by now. If someone wants to fight over here in my blog, well they best be prepared.

  3. I love the sass in this post 😂 I had reviewing DNF books on my list 😳 I agree the loads of edition things is wasteful and I always think these people are spending a fortune for just one book 🙄 I never really thought about the have to read thing but I agree! And am guilty 😳 I totally agree about the cover changing and diversity thing! Great list!
    My list:

  4. Pingback: June 2019 Wrap-Up | YA on my Mind

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.