Review: Scum’s Wish: Volume 1

Scum's Wish: Volume 1Scum’s Wish: Volume 1 by Mengo Yokoyari
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

17-year-old Awaya Mugi and Yasuraoka Hanabi appear to be the ideal couple. They are both pretty popular, and they seem to suit each other well. However, outsiders don’t know of the secret they share. Both Mugi and Hanabi have hopeless crushes on someone else, and they are only dating each other to soothe their loneliness. Mugi is in love with Minagawa Akane, a young teacher who used to be his home tutor. Hanabi is also in love with a teacher, a young man who has been a family friend since she was little. In each other, they find a place where they can grieve for the ones they cannot have, and they share a loneliness-driven physical intimacy. Will things stay like this for them forever?

Friends with benefits is not really a novel concept but to see it being done in a shoujo-esque setting feels very different. Granted, it is categorized as seinen, but I don’t believe in there being girl books and boy books, so there. All I will categorize it as is young adult, and it is intense for that. Reader discretion seriously advised – as this story is a little messed up. Mugi and Hanabi both love other people but since both those people are out of their reach, they form a pact to find a surrogate in each other. It’s a consensual deal, so who am I to judge, right? But there are other secondary characters that are in love with them, and them being obsessed by their respective unrequited loves and the twisted deal they make with each other sort of closes them off from the possibility of having a normal love life.

The characters are both human, in that you might not like them, but also can’t help rooting for them. I mostly started this because the anime just released, so I am a bit anxious as to how this story might proceed. It doesn’t look like it is going to be an easy path for them both, because they have to break out of this hold, but I am sort of rooting for Hanabi to notice Ecchan? I don’t know, Mugi and Hanabi also seem great but their shared history might always cast a shadow over any future happiness. The artwork is good, and the color pages shine with translucent-like paint styles, but it is really not that extraordinary; it does not particularly stand out for me. I would probably pick up future translated issues after seeing the anime and judging how it goes.

View all my reviews


3 thoughts on “Review: Scum’s Wish: Volume 1

  1. I’m excited to give the anime series a watch very soon, probably once it finishes airing. And yes, I totally agree that the idea that fiction is exclusive to a gender is a fallacy, great storytelling can be enjoyed by anyone!

    • I look forward to reading your analysis of it when you are done with the anime!

      Honestly the genre classification for manga is excessive. There are so many great stories when you don’t stick to genre or its expected tropes.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.